Alone onstage just before his set, Miles Benjamin Anthony Robinson mentioned to the crowd that this would be the first live performance with him fronting his new band, "The Family Robinson." "But don't be surprised," he continued, "if we fuck something up." Not to be a schmuck, but isn't that kind of the point here? I mean, if we really wanted to see a band that deals in inspirational, emotive major chord bar rock and is more proficient/less damaged than Miles, wouldn't we all be Hold Steady/Okkervil River/Bruce fans?
Having seen Miles Benjamin Anthony Robinson once prior, and enjoying his album quite a bit (#19 on my most recent Best Albums of 2008 so far list), coming into this show I still didn't know what to make of him. He certainly plays the "junkie confessional" part quite well, and he's certainly inspired his share of hyperbolic press. (From Daytrotter: "He’s everything that we’re looking for in an indie rock idol.") And his nomadic junkie past seems ripe for this brand of lecherous voyeurism. (From the Village Voice: "life definitely handed Miles Benjamin Anthony Robinson loads of lemons
(and first names), but he chose Atmosphere's route and painted that
shit gold.") So you'll have to pardon my reluctance to anoint him as the second coming of anything. Well, at least until he played his set.
I've written before that MBAR manages to evoke greatness in his songs, and I stand by that: his itchy, bombastic guitar playing reminds me of Neil Young; his mumbly lower register reminds me of Dylan; his tortured upper register bleat reminds me of, uh, Dylan, and his ability to rock out a simple three-chord song to arena-size dimensions reminds me of Tom Petty. (What was that I was saying about hyperbole?) The set included favorites from his self-titled debut (including standout "Buriedfed," which kinda reminds me of Okkervil's "This Is Not a Movie or Maybe," and "Who's Laughing") as well as plenty of unreleased stuff "from the second album" (reportedly helmed by TV on the Radio's Kyp Malone) and, wryly, "the third album." The set's real strength was found in the louder jams which were rocked to the hilt, the four piece Family Robinsons backing him up ably (and, fittingly, shambolically) throughout. New song "There Will Be Mud" in particular all but brought the house down with its ambling instrumental coda. Make no mistake: Miles Benjamin Anthony Robinson knows how to rock, pure and simple.
So what's tonight's lesson, kids? When it comes down to it it isn't
necessarily authenticity for authenticity's sake that really matters
all that much, is it? Were that the case, your friendly neighborhood Singin'
Homeless Dude would have a lot more than a few bucks and change in his
cup. Seriously, who the fuck cares. On with the music.